The short answer
To set up a mentoring program that pairs older students with younger ones, first decide what the program is for, such as reading support, helping new students settle or transition to a new school phase. Then schedule a regular, protected time for pairs to meet, recruit and screen older student mentors, match pairs using a short questionnaire and staff knowledge, and train mentors before the first meeting. Assign a staff coordinator to supervise sessions and check in with mentors, keep families informed, and measure attendance at sessions, relationship quality and one or two outcomes linked to your goal. End the year with a planned closure so pairs finish well.
A widely used framework is MENTOR's Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring, which sets out research informed standards for recruitment, screening, training, matching and initiating, monitoring and support, and closure. This guide adapts those ideas to a school run program where both mentors and mentees are students.
Why cross age mentoring works
Cross age mentoring, where an older student mentors a younger one, can help both students. Younger students get a relatable role model, extra attention and a friendly face in school. Older students build responsibility, empathy and leadership, and often say they feel more connected to school themselves.
It also fits school life well. Pairs meet on site, during the school day or a set after school slot, with adults close by. Unlike adult mentoring, schools do not need to recruit outside volunteers, and the program can become part of school culture as mentees later become mentors.
Cross age mentoring is not a replacement for professional support. Students with serious academic, social or emotional needs still need specialist staff. Mentors should be friends and role models, not tutors, counselors or disciplinarians.
Set clear goals and scope
A program with a clear purpose is easier to design, explain and measure. Pick one main goal to start.
| Program goal | Typical pairing | Example activities |
|---|---|---|
| Reading support | Grade 5 with Grade 1 or 2 | Shared reading, talking about books, reading games |
| Transition to a new school | Older middle or high school students with incoming students | Tours, lunch meetups, Q and A about school life |
| Belonging and wellbeing | Older students with younger students who need a friendly connection | Games, projects, conversations, shared interests |
| New arrivals and language learners | Older students who share a language or experience | Orientation, buddy support in the first weeks |
Write a one page program description that covers the goal, who can take part, when pairs meet, what mentors do and do not do, and who coordinates it. Share it with staff, students and families.
Plan the structure and schedule
- Choose a coordinator. One staff member owns the program: recruitment, matching, training, scheduling, check ins and records.
- Fix a regular time. Weekly or every other week sessions of 20 to 40 minutes, at the same time each week, build relationships better than occasional meetings.
- Choose a supervised space. Sessions take place in a classroom, library or hall with an adult present. Avoid unsupervised one to one meetings.
- Set the length of the commitment. Ask for a full term or full year. Short matches that end early can disappoint younger students.
- Plan session content. Give mentors a simple menu of activities so they are never stuck, while leaving room for pairs to choose.
Recruit and screen mentors
Good mentors are reliable and kind, not only high achievers. Some of the best mentors are students who have faced challenges themselves.
- Invite applications with a short form asking why the student wants to mentor and what they could share.
- Ask staff for nominations and check attendance and reliability.
- Talk to each applicant briefly about the role and expectations.
- Get consent from families of mentors and mentees, using your school's normal consent process.
- Set clear expectations in a simple mentor agreement: attend every session, be kind and patient, keep the mentee's personal information private except for safety concerns, and tell the coordinator about any worries.
Match pairs carefully
Matching affects whether pairs click. Combine a short questionnaire with staff knowledge.
- Collect interests from mentors and mentees: hobbies, favorite subjects, languages spoken and what they hope to get from the program.
- Add staff insight. Teachers know which personalities might work well together and which pairs to avoid.
- Match on shared interests and goals first, then consider schedules and any practical needs.
- Keep a small reserve of trained mentors to cover absences or rematches.
- Record each match with the date, goal and coordinator notes so you can track progress.
Keep groups flexible. Some schools use one mentor with two mentees, or small group mentoring, when mentor numbers are low.
Train mentors before they start
Training is the step schools most often skip, and the one that most affects quality. Plan at least one session before the first meeting and short refreshers during the year.
- The role: what a mentor is and is not.
- Building a relationship: listening, asking open questions, being consistent and showing up.
- Session ideas: how to use the activity menu, how to read together or play learning games.
- Boundaries and safety: how to respond if a mentee shares something worrying, and the rule that safety concerns always go to the coordinator.
- Difficult moments: what to do if a mentee is quiet, upset or off task.
- Ending well: how the program will close and why saying goodbye matters.
Prepare mentees too. A short introduction explains what a mentor is and how sessions work.
Run sessions and support pairs
- Start with a launch session where pairs meet, share interests and set a simple goal together.
- Keep a light routine: a check in, an activity and a short reflection.
- Circulate during sessions. The coordinator or supervising adult moves between pairs, helps where needed and notes any concerns.
- Hold mentor check ins every few weeks to share what is working and solve problems.
- Track attendance of pairs. Missed sessions are the earliest warning sign that a match is struggling.
- Rematch quickly if a pair is not working after support.
- Close the year well with a celebration, a short reflection or a letter from mentor to mentee, so the relationship ends positively.
Measure whether it works
Pick a few measures linked to your goal and collect them simply.
| Measure | How to collect it | When |
|---|---|---|
| Session attendance | Coordinator records for each pair | Every session |
| Relationship quality | Short survey for mentors and mentees | Mid year and end of year |
| Goal outcome | Reading data, attendance, transition survey or belonging survey, depending on your goal | Start and end of year |
| Mentor growth | Mentor reflection on confidence and leadership | End of year |
| Staff and family feedback | Short questions in existing surveys | End of year |
Compare outcomes with a sensible baseline, but be careful about claiming the program caused changes. Use the results to improve matching, training and session content for the following year.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Starting too big. A small, well run program builds trust; a large, poorly supported one burns out.
- No protected time. Sessions that get canceled for other activities break relationships.
- Skipping training, leaving mentors unsure what to do.
- Choosing only top students and missing caring mentors with different strengths.
- Unsupervised meetings that create safeguarding risks.
- No planned ending, so matches fade without a goodbye.
Mentoring program checklist
- One clear goal and a one page program description
- Named staff coordinator
- Regular, protected, supervised session time
- Mentor applications, staff nominations and consent
- Mentor agreement with expectations and safety rules
- Matching questionnaire plus staff input
- Mentor training before the first session and refreshers
- Mentee introduction and launch session
- Attendance tracking and regular mentor check ins
- Simple measures linked to the goal and a planned closure
How Borderset helps
Borderset keeps the admin of a mentoring program in one place. Student tracking keeps guardian details and coordinator notes on each student's profile, so the coordinator can see the history of every match. Schedule management books the weekly session slot and room, and Announcements keep families of mentors and mentees informed. To see how it would work for your program, book a demo.
Related reading on Borderset
Reading buddies are a natural part of a school wide reading culture. To give older students more leadership roles, see how to run a student council with real impact. For the wider climate a mentoring program supports, read how to build a positive school culture around behavior.
Frequently asked questions
What is cross age mentoring?
It is a program where older students mentor younger students, usually at least two grades apart, meeting regularly with adult supervision to build a supportive relationship.
How often should student mentors and mentees meet?
Weekly or every other week sessions of 20 to 40 minutes at the same time each week work well. Consistency matters more than session length.
How do you match mentors and mentees?
Use a short questionnaire on interests, languages and goals, combine it with teacher knowledge of the students, then match on shared interests and practical needs.
What training do student mentors need?
At least one session before the first meeting covering the role, building a relationship, activity ideas, boundaries, what to do with safety concerns and how the program will end.
How do you know if a mentoring program works?
Track session attendance, survey relationship quality, measure one or two outcomes linked to the goal and gather feedback from mentors, staff and families.
Should mentors be the highest achieving students?
Not necessarily. Reliability, kindness and patience matter most, and students who have faced challenges can be especially good mentors.