Skip to content
Operations

Teacher Shortages in 2026: What LPI's 425,400 Figure Means for School Leaders

Jordan Lee · Education Product Lead, Borderset · 8 min read

The Learning Policy Institute's State Teacher Shortages 2026 Update estimates that at least 425,412 teaching positions in the United States are either unfilled or held by teachers who are not fully certified for their assignment, about 1 in 8 positions nationally. For school leaders, the lesson is that shortages are now mostly a quality and retention problem, not only a vacancy problem.

The short answer

The State Teacher Shortages 2026 Update from the Learning Policy Institute (LPI), published in July 2026, counts 387,843 teachers who are not fully certified for their assignments across all 50 states and the District of Columbia, plus 37,569 unfilled positions in the 29 states and DC that publish vacancy data. Together that is a minimum of 425,412 positions, roughly 1 in 8 teaching jobs.

For a school leader, that means three things. Plan for hard to fill roles a year ahead. Treat retention as your cheapest hiring strategy. And support the teachers you already have who are still working toward full certification, because they are now a large part of the workforce. Facts in this post were checked against the sources on 19 November 2026.

What the LPI 2026 update found

LPI reviewed state teacher workforce reports and agency documents and used the most recent year each state had available, between 2023-24 and 2025-26. The total number of teachers comes from the National Center for Education Statistics Common Core of Data for 2024-25, which puts full time equivalent teachers at 3,253,316.

Measure2026 update2025 update
Teachers not fully certified for their assignment387,843 (50 states + DC)365,967 (48 states + DC)
Unfilled teaching positions37,569 (29 states + DC report)45,582 (31 states + DC report)
Minimum total affected positions425,412411,549
Share of teaching positionsAbout 1 in 8About 1 in 8

Sources: LPI 2026 update and LPI 2025 update. The two years are not perfectly comparable because the set of reporting states changed.

LPI's own comparison of states that reported in both years shows the direction of travel. In states with vacancy data in both scans, unfilled positions fell by about 7,000, a 16% decrease. In states with certification data in both scans, teachers who are not fully certified rose by about 15,800, or 4%. LPI says this is the third year in a row that the combined total has risen. In short, schools are filling more posts, but more often with teachers who are not yet fully prepared.

What "not fully certified" means

The phrase covers several different groups, and states define and report them differently. LPI's 2026 resource tool groups them as:

  • Teachers with no credential.
  • Teachers on emergency or temporary credentials, including long term substitutes.
  • Interns or alternative route teachers still completing preparation.
  • Teachers working out of field, outside the subject or grade their license covers.

LPI notes that all values should be read as estimates and that the figures are an undercount, because some states do not report and others report only some schools. Do not compare your state's number with another state's without reading how each one counts.

State examples

Shortages look very different from state to state. A few figures from LPI's state table, each for the most recent year that state reported:

StateWhat LPI reports
California (2023-24)35,182 teachers not fully certified out of 267,944 FTE teachers
Georgia (2024-25)21,500 not fully certified out of 124,125 FTE teachers
New York (2024-25)18,583 teachers working out of field out of 218,424 FTE teachers
Louisiana (2024-25)17,131 not fully certified or out of field out of 48,637 FTE teachers
Arizona4,242 FTE vacancies in September 2025 and 8,181 not fully certified in 2024-25
Mississippi3,815 unfilled positions in fall 2025

LPI also lists seven states where the number of teachers who are not fully certified rose by 20% or more between 2023-24 and 2024-25: Hawaii, Kentucky, Maryland, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada and Oklahoma. Check your own state's report for your local picture.

What school leaders see on the ground

Federal survey data matches what principals describe. In the National Center for Education Statistics School Pulse Panel release of October 2024, based on responses collected in August 2024, the average public school had six teaching vacancies for 2024-25 and filled 79% of them with fully certified teachers before classes started. That rate was 72% in high poverty schools. Seventy four percent of schools reported difficulty filling at least one teaching vacancy, and the most common reasons were too few qualified candidates and too few applicants. Special education was the hardest area to fill in elementary and middle schools, and English as a second language or bilingual roles in high schools. NCES labels this an experimental data product.

Why retention matters more than recruitment

Most teaching vacancies each year are created by teachers leaving before retirement, according to LPI's 2024 analysis of the cost of teacher turnover. LPI estimates that larger districts can spend nearly $25,000 on average to replace a teacher who leaves, once recruitment, hiring and training are counted. Its earlier work, summarised in a district fact sheet, reports that teachers hired without full preparation leave at two to three times the rate of fully prepared teachers.

That creates a cycle. A school short of candidates hires underprepared teachers, more of them leave, and the next year's vacancies grow. Breaking the cycle means investing in the teachers you have as well as finding new ones.

Hiring strategies that help

LPI's recommendations for districts focus on hiring earlier and widening the pipeline:

  1. Hire early. Post roles and make offers in the spring before the school year, not in August. Ask staff for early notice of resignation or retirement, and consider a small incentive for notice given by a fixed date.
  2. Partner with preparation programs. Host student teachers and residents. LPI's 2024 report on teacher residencies found that residency prepared teachers typically stay in teaching at higher rates than other new teachers in their districts.
  3. Grow your own. Support paraprofessionals, substitutes and graduates from your community who want to teach, including help with preparation costs through service scholarships or loan forgiveness where your state offers them.
  4. Remove friction for experienced transfers. Give full salary credit for prior experience so experienced teachers are not penalised for moving.
  5. Target hard to fill areas. Use your own data to see which subjects and grades are slow to fill, often special education, English learner roles, math and science, and start those searches first.

Retention strategies that help

LPI groups its retention recommendations into four areas. All of them are within reach of a school or district, though some cost more than others.

AreaWhat it looks like in a school
Strong preparationSupport for teachers on temporary or emergency licences to complete certification, with time and coaching
Mentoring and inductionA trained, paid mentor for every new teacher, a lighter load in year one and shared planning time
Working conditionsStrong principals, regular teacher surveys, common planning time and a real voice in decisions
Pay and incentivesCompetitive salaries, stipends for mentor and leadership roles and for high need subjects or schools, and housing or loan help where possible

Source: LPI, What's the Cost of Teacher Turnover? (2024).

Working conditions are often the part a principal controls most directly. A fair timetable, protected planning time and less administrative work make a measurable difference to whether teachers stay. Our guides on reducing teacher admin workload and timetables that reduce teacher burnout cover practical steps, and the 90 day new teacher onboarding plan sets out a first year structure.

A one term plan for school leaders

  1. Know your numbers. List every vacancy, every teacher on a temporary or emergency licence and every out of field assignment, with expected certification dates.
  2. Check who is at risk of leaving. Look at turnover by department and years of experience, and talk to teachers before spring decisions. Our post on teacher retention metrics that matter suggests what to track.
  3. Set up mentoring. Match every new and not fully certified teacher with a mentor and protect time for them to meet.
  4. Track certification progress. Record coursework, exams and licence expiry dates so nobody's temporary licence lapses unnoticed. See teacher credentials and PD tracking.
  5. Start next year's hiring now. Draft postings for the roles you know will be hard to fill and contact local preparation programs in the winter.
  6. Plan cover. Build a reliable substitute pool so vacancies do not fall on the remaining staff. Our substitute teacher coverage guide explains how.

How Borderset helps

Borderset keeps teacher information in one place. With teacher tracking, leaders can see each teacher's subjects, schedule and workload, and with schedule management they can plan cover and make up lessons without spreadsheets. Role based access means mentors and leaders see what they need and nothing more. If you want to see how it would work for your staff, book a demo.

For pay and long term retention, read our post on North Carolina's veteran teacher pay priorities. To build a culture of feedback, see how to set up a teacher peer observation program, for recruitment copy, our guide to writing teacher job postings that attract strong candidates, and for fair reviews, our guide to running fair teacher evaluation.

Frequently asked questions

How many teaching positions are affected by the shortage in 2026?

The Learning Policy Institute's 2026 update estimates at least 425,412 positions are unfilled or held by teachers not fully certified for their assignment, about 1 in 8 teaching positions nationally.

Is the teacher shortage getting better or worse?

Mixed. In states that reported both years, unfilled positions fell by about 16%, but teachers who are not fully certified rose by about 4%, and the combined total rose for the third year in a row.

What does not fully certified mean?

It includes teachers with no credential, teachers on emergency or temporary credentials, interns or alternative route teachers still in preparation, and teachers working out of field. States define and report these groups differently.

Which teaching roles are hardest to fill?

In the NCES School Pulse Panel for 2024-25, special education was hardest to fill in elementary and middle schools, and English as a second language or bilingual roles in high schools.

What is the most cost effective way to reduce shortages?

Retention. LPI estimates larger districts can spend nearly $25,000 to replace a teacher, and most vacancies come from teachers leaving before retirement, so mentoring, good working conditions and fair pay pay off.

Where can I find my state's shortage data?

LPI's 2026 resource tool lists each state's latest figures and links to the state source, so you can read how your state counts vacancies and certification.

Back to all posts