Skip to content
Operations playbook

How to Write a School Improvement Plan, Step by Step

Anika Iyer · K-12 Analytics Lead, Borderset · 8 min read

A good school improvement plan is short, specific and checked often. This guide walks through the full cycle: a needs assessment, root causes, a few SMART goals, action steps with named owners, and progress checks that keep the plan alive after it is approved.

The short answer

To write a school improvement plan, start with a needs assessment that looks at student outcomes, attendance, climate, staffing and resources. Pick two or three priorities, find their root causes, and turn each into a SMART goal. For every goal, list the actions, the person who owns each one, the deadline, the resources needed and the evidence you will check. Then review progress on a fixed schedule, at least every six to eight weeks, and adjust.

Many plans fail not because the goals are wrong but because nobody looks at them again until the next deadline. The steps below are designed to prevent that. If your school is identified for comprehensive support and improvement under the federal Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), some elements are required by law; see when a plan is required below.

Step 1: Build a small team and a calendar

Name a core team of five to eight people: the principal or head of school, an assistant principal or academic lead, two or three teachers from different grades or departments, a student support lead such as a counselor, and, where possible, a family representative. A data lead who can pull reports quickly saves weeks.

Before you look at any data, put the whole cycle on the calendar: needs assessment dates, the draft deadline, approval meetings and every progress review for the year. Plans that have review dates booked from the start are far more likely to be reviewed.

Step 2: Run a needs assessment

A needs assessment answers one question: where is the gap between what students need and what they are getting? Look across several types of evidence, not only test scores.

AreaExamples of evidenceQuestions to ask
Academic outcomesState and interim assessments, course pass rates, reading benchmarks, exam resultsWhich groups, grades or subjects are furthest from goal? Is the gap growing?
Attendance and engagementChronic absenteeism, tardies, course completion, participationWho is missing learning time, and when?
Behavior and climateIncidents, suspensions, student and staff surveysWhere and when do problems cluster?
StaffingVacancies, turnover, teacher experience, professional developmentDo the students with the greatest needs have stable, experienced teachers?
Family engagementConference attendance, portal use, survey responsesWhich families are we not reaching?
ResourcesBudget by program, schedules, materials, technologyAre resources aligned with the biggest needs?

Disaggregate every measure by grade, student group and, in multi-campus organizations, by site. Averages hide the patterns you need to act on. Write down three to five findings in plain language, for example: "Grade 6 math proficiency has fallen two years running, and the drop is largest among students who were chronically absent in grade 5."

Step 3: Find root causes

A finding is not a cause. Low math scores might come from gaps in core instruction, missing intervention time, high teacher turnover, attendance, or a curriculum that does not match standards. If you skip this step, you will fund solutions to the wrong problem.

Two simple tools help. The "five whys" asks why a problem happens, then why that happens, until you reach something the school can control. A fishbone diagram sorts possible causes into categories such as instruction, time, people, materials and policies. Test each likely cause against evidence, such as classroom observations, schedules or student interviews, before you commit to it.

Step 4: Choose a few priorities and write SMART goals

Limit the plan to two or three priorities. A plan with ten goals usually becomes a list of everything the school already does. For each priority, write a goal that is Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant and Time-bound.

Weak goalSMART goal
Improve math achievementIncrease the share of grade 6 students meeting the spring math benchmark from 41% to 50% by May 2027
Reduce absencesReduce chronic absenteeism among grades 7 and 8 from 22% to 17% by the end of the 2026-27 school year
Better family engagementRaise attendance at fall and spring conferences from 60% to 75% of families, with every family contacted at least twice

The numbers above are illustrations, not benchmarks. Set targets from your own baseline: ambitious enough to matter, realistic enough that staff believe them. Add one or two leading indicators per goal, such as weekly attendance or interim assessment results, so you can see progress before the end-of-year data arrives.

Step 5: Plan the actions, owners and resources

Each goal needs a short list of actions that address the root cause. For every action, record:

  • What will happen, described concretely enough that someone could observe it.
  • Who owns it. One named person, not a team or a department.
  • When it starts and finishes, with milestones.
  • Resources: time in the schedule, staff, training, materials and budget lines.
  • Evidence: what you will check to know it is happening and working.
ActionOwnerTimelineResourcesEvidence of progress
Add a 30-minute math intervention block for grade 6Assistant principalStart of term 2Timetable change, intervention materialsAttendance at intervention; interim scores every 6 weeks
Weekly attendance review with a named adult for each flagged studentCounselorFrom week 330 minutes a week; attendance reportStudents contacted within 5 days; weekly attendance trend
Common planning time for grade 6 math teachersDepartment leadTerm 2 onwardOne shared period per weekMeeting notes; shared assessments used

Where you choose interventions, prefer approaches with evidence behind them and say what the evidence is. If your school must follow ESSA requirements, evidence-based interventions are mandatory for identified schools.

Step 6: Monitor progress and adjust

Set a progress check every six to eight weeks. Each review should take under an hour and answer four questions: Did we do what we said? What do the leading indicators show? What is getting in the way? What will we change before the next check?

Use a simple status for each action, such as on track, at risk or off track, and record decisions. Share a one-page summary with staff after each review. At the end of the year, compare results with the SMART targets and carry the lessons into the next needs assessment.

When a school improvement plan is required

Requirements vary by state and school type. In the United States, two federal provisions are common reasons a plan is required:

  • Comprehensive support and improvement (CSI). Under ESSA, for each school the state identifies, the district must work with stakeholders, including principals, teachers and parents, to develop a plan that is informed by all state accountability indicators, includes evidence-based interventions, is based on a school-level needs assessment, identifies resource inequities, is approved by the school, district and state, and is then monitored by the state (20 U.S.C. 6311(d)). Targeted support schools have similar planning duties.
  • Title I schoolwide programs. Schools that run a Title I schoolwide program must base their plan on a comprehensive needs assessment of the whole school (20 U.S.C. 6314).

Many states also require annual improvement plans for all public schools, often in a set template, and independent schools may need one for accreditation. Check your state or accreditor's template first and map the steps above onto it. This section is general information, not legal advice.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Too many goals, so nothing gets real attention.
  • Goals written as activities ("implement a new curriculum") rather than outcomes.
  • No baseline, so progress cannot be measured.
  • Actions owned by "all staff", which means no one.
  • Only annual data, so problems surface after the year is over.
  • A plan written by one person and filed, with no staff ownership.

A one-page plan template

Whatever template your state or network requires, a one-page summary helps staff see the whole plan at a glance. Use one row per goal:

FieldWhat to write
PriorityThe problem in one sentence, from the needs assessment
Root causeThe cause you are addressing, with the evidence behind it
SMART goalBaseline, target, measure and date
Leading indicatorsOne or two measures you will check every six to eight weeks
Key actionsThree to five actions, each with an owner and a deadline
ResourcesTime, people, training and budget
Review datesThe dates of every progress check this year

Pin the summary in the staff room or share it in your staff portal, and update the status of each action after every review.

How Borderset helps you run the plan

A plan is only as good as the data behind its progress checks. Borderset keeps attendance, grades and exam results on each student record, so needs assessments and six-week reviews do not start with a spreadsheet hunt. Exam management ties assessment results to students and classes, and teacher tracking shows assignments and workload when you plan actions and owners. To see how your improvement data could sit in one place, book a demo.

To choose the measures for your progress checks, read key metrics every principal should track each term and exam analytics: what to track per term.

If attendance is one of your priorities, see chronic absenteeism in 2025-26: the latest data and strategies.

To check progress halfway through the year, use our December mid year review checklist for school goals.

Frequently asked questions

What should a school improvement plan include?

A needs assessment summary, two or three priorities with root causes, SMART goals with baselines and targets, action steps with a named owner, timeline, resources and evidence for each, and a schedule of progress reviews.

How many goals should a school improvement plan have?

Two or three is usually enough. Fewer goals get more attention, staff time and resources, and are easier to monitor.

What is a needs assessment in school improvement?

It is a structured review of evidence such as achievement, attendance, behavior, climate surveys, staffing and resources, broken down by grade, student group and site, to find the biggest gaps between what students need and what they receive.

How often should a school improvement plan be reviewed?

Review progress every six to eight weeks using leading indicators such as attendance and interim assessments, and do a full review at the end of the year that feeds the next needs assessment.

Is a school improvement plan required by law?

It depends on the school. Under ESSA, schools identified for comprehensive support and improvement must have a plan that meets federal requirements and is approved by the school, district and state. Many states also require annual plans for all public schools.

What is the difference between a goal and an action step?

A goal describes the result you want, such as a higher benchmark pass rate by a date. An action step describes what people will do to get there, such as adding an intervention block, with an owner and a deadline.

Back to all posts