Skip to content
Operations playbook

How to Run a Mid Year Review of School Goals in December: A Simple Checklist

Anika Iyer · K-12 Analytics Lead, Borderset · 6 min read

A mid year review is a short, structured check, usually in December, on whether your school goals are on track. Pull a small set of data for each goal, ask staff and students what they are seeing, rate each goal as on track, at risk or off track, and agree no more than three course corrections before the second semester starts.

The short answer

Run the review in three steps over two to three weeks. First, gather evidence: for each school goal, pull the one or two measures named in your plan, plus attendance, behavior and interim assessment data. Second, listen: run a short staff survey and a few student and family conversations. Third, decide: in one leadership meeting, rate every goal, find the likely cause of any gap and choose what to keep, adjust or stop. Then tell staff and families what will change in January.

The goal is not a new plan. It is a better second half of the year.

Why December is the right time

By December most schools have one full grading period, a first round of interim assessments and enough attendance data to see patterns. There is still a full semester left to act on what you find. Waiting until spring leaves too little time, and reviewing in October gives you too little data.

The U.S. Department of Education's guidance on using evidence describes improvement as a cycle that ends with a step to examine and reflect on what happened, then adjust. A mid year review builds that step into the calendar instead of leaving it to the end of the year. If you are still drafting your plan, start with our guide on how to write a school improvement plan.

Step 1: Gather the right data

Keep the data pack small. For each goal, use the measure your plan already names, then add a few school wide indicators. Avoid building new reports in December; use what your systems already hold.

AreaWhat to pullQuestion to ask
Each school goalThe measure and target named in the planAre we on pace to hit the year end target?
AttendanceAverage daily attendance and the share of students missing 10 percent or more of daysWhich groups or grades are slipping?
Academic progressGrade distributions and interim assessment results by subject and gradeWhere are more students below expectations than in the fall?
BehaviorReferrals, suspensions and incidents by monthIs anything rising, and where and when?
Family engagementConference attendance and responses to school messagesWhich families are we not reaching?
StaffingVacancies, absences and substitute coverageDo staffing gaps explain any of the results?

Show each measure as a trend from the start of the year, not a single number. Our guides on attendance dashboards that drive intervention and exam analytics to track per term explain how to read these patterns.

Step 2: Gather staff, student and family feedback

Data shows what is happening. People explain why. Collect both before the leadership meeting.

  • Staff survey: five or six questions, anonymous, open for one week. Ask which actions in the plan are happening as intended, what gets in the way and what one change would help most.
  • Department or grade team discussions: fifteen minutes in an existing meeting, using the same questions, with one person taking notes.
  • Student voice: a few small group conversations or a short survey for older students about what helps them learn and what does not.
  • Family input: a short question in your newsletter or at conferences, or a quick call to a small sample of families.

Keep it short. A long survey in the busiest month of the year will get low response and tired answers.

Step 3: Rate each goal

Use a simple three level rating so the conversation focuses on action, not on debating labels.

RatingMeaningTypical response
On trackProgress is at or ahead of the pace needed to meet the year end targetKeep going; protect what is working
At riskProgress is behind pace, but the gap is small or the cause is knownAdjust one or two actions; check again in six weeks
Off trackProgress is well behind or moving the wrong wayFind the root cause; change the approach or reset the target with a clear reason

For each at risk or off track goal, ask whether the actions in the plan are actually happening. Many gaps come from implementation, such as an intervention that is scheduled but not delivered, rather than from a bad strategy.

Step 4: Choose course corrections

Hold one leadership meeting of about two hours. A simple agenda:

  1. Review the rating for each goal and the main evidence (30 minutes).
  2. Discuss the staff, student and family feedback (20 minutes).
  3. For goals at risk or off track, agree the likely cause (30 minutes).
  4. Decide what to keep, adjust or stop, limited to three changes in total (30 minutes).
  5. Assign an owner, first step and check in date for each change (10 minutes).

Limit yourself to three changes. Every new initiative takes time from something else, and staff energy in January is not unlimited. Stopping an action that is not working is a valid correction and often frees time for one that is.

Step 5: Communicate and update the plan

Close the loop before the break. Staff should hear the results and the changes from leaders, not through rumor.

  • Share a one page summary with staff: each goal's rating, what you heard from them and the three changes.
  • Update the improvement plan document and the calendar for January.
  • Tell families what the school is focusing on in the second semester in your next newsletter. Our guide on how to write a school newsletter has a simple structure.
  • If you report to a board, use the same summary. See how to present to your school board.
  • Set the date of the next check, usually in March.

Mid year review checklist

  • Review dates set for early to mid December
  • Data pack built for every goal with trend since the start of the year
  • Attendance, behavior, academic, family and staffing indicators included
  • Staff survey sent and closed
  • Student and family feedback collected
  • Each goal rated on track, at risk or off track
  • Root cause discussed for every goal at risk or off track
  • No more than three course corrections, each with an owner and a date
  • Plan document and January calendar updated
  • Summary shared with staff, families and the board
  • Next check scheduled for March

Common mistakes

  • Building a new plan in December. Adjust the existing one.
  • Too much data. A forty page data pack hides the few numbers that matter.
  • Skipping staff input. Teachers often know why a goal is slipping before the data shows it.
  • Adding initiatives without stopping any. It overloads staff and dilutes effort.
  • No follow up. A correction without an owner and a check in date usually does not happen.

How Borderset helps

Borderset keeps the data for a mid year review in one place, so leaders spend the time on decisions instead of spreadsheets. Student tracking brings attendance, profiles and notes together, exam management shows grades and progress over the term, and announcements help you share second semester priorities with families. To see your school's data this way, book a demo.

For the measures to watch through the year, see key metrics every principal should track each term. To make your review meetings more efficient, read how to run effective staff meetings, and if attendance is a priority, see chronic absenteeism in 2025-26: the latest data and strategies.

Frequently asked questions

When should a school run a mid year review of its goals?

Most schools run it in early to mid December, after the first grading period and interim assessments, so there is still a full semester to act on the findings.

What data should a mid year review include?

The measure named for each school goal, plus attendance, academic progress, behavior, family engagement and staffing data, shown as trends since the start of the year.

How do you rate progress on school goals?

Use three levels: on track if progress is at or ahead of pace, at risk if it is slightly behind or the cause is known, and off track if it is well behind or moving the wrong way.

How many changes should come out of a mid year review?

Aim for no more than three course corrections, each with an owner, a first step and a check in date. Stopping something that is not working counts as a correction.

Who should take part in a mid year review?

The leadership team makes the decisions, but staff, students and families should give input first through short surveys and conversations.

Back to all posts